DOMICILE IN MARRIAGE, DIVORCE, SUCCESSION & INHERITANCE BY ANIL* AND ANKIT MALHOTRA**






DOMICILE IN MARRIAGE, DIVORCE, SUCCESSION & INHERITANCE
BY ANIL* AND ANKIT MALHOTRA**
SIGNIFICANCE OF DOMICILE
The concept of domicile plays a pivotal role in determining an individual's legal status in areas such as succession, inheritance, and personal law, both in Indian and English jurisprudence. Domicile is essentially a person’s permanent home or the place where they intend to reside indefinitely, and it influences the application of laws concerning property, marriage, taxation, and inheritance. In legal terms, domicile is categorised into three types: domicile of origin, domicile by operation of law, and domicile of choice. Each of these forms holds significance in different legal scenarios, especially in succession matters where the domicile of the deceased influences the distribution of their assets. Indian courts, in numerous landmark judgments, have interpreted and elucidated the principles governing domicile. In Sondur Gopal v. Sondur Rajini, 2013 (7) Supreme Court Cases 426 the Supreme Court of India provided clarity on the distinction between domicile of origin and domicile of choice. It reaffirmed that the domicile of origin continues to prevail until a new domicile is consciously acquired with a clear intention to abandon the original one. This case forms the foundation of Indian legal principles on domicile, illustrating how residence and intention collectively determine one’s domicile.
LAW LAID DOWN BY THE COURTS
It may be useful to quote here the views of the Supreme Court on the concept of domicile, as well as on how domicile of origin, domicile by operation of law, and domicile of choice have found brief interpretation. In this regard, judgment of Supreme Court in Sondur Gopal v. Sondur Rajini (supra) is relied upon & quoted hereunder for ready reference:
“26. Domiciles are of three kinds, viz. the domicile of origin, the domicile by operation of law, and the domicile of choice. In the present case, we are concerned only with the domicile of origin and domicile of choice. Domicile of origin is not necessarily the place of birth. The birth of a child at a place during the temporary absence of the parents from their domicile will not make the place of birth the domicile of the child. In the domicile of choice, one is abandoned and another domicile is acquired but for that, the acquisition of another domicile is not sufficient. Domicile of origin prevails until not only another domicile is acquired but it must manifest the intention of abandoning the domicile of origin...
27. The right to change the domicile of birth is available to any person not legally dependent and such a person can acquire a domicile of choice. It is done by residing in the country of choice with the intention of continuing to reside there indefinitely. Unless proved, there is a presumption against the change of domicile. Therefore, the person who alleges it has to prove that. Intention is always lodged in the mind, which can be inferred from any act, event or circumstance in the life of such person...” (Emphasis supplied).
In, Shilpa Sachdev v. Shri. Anand Sachdev AIR 2017-5 Bom R 607, the Bombay High Court held that the Dubai Court was not a competent authority to oversee the divorce proceedings. The High Court highlighted several issues: the respondent-husband did not claim the petitioner-wife was a resident or domicile of Dubai; there were no statements indicating she had permanently moved to Dubai; and the Dubai Court's judgment did not state she was domiciled there. Records showed that the wife had returned to India on June 21, 2008, and has been permanently domiciled in India. Both parties were Indian citizens, and in the absence of evidence proving domicile in Dubai, the presumption under Section 14 of the Code of Civil Procedure, 1908 remained unsubstantiated. Moreover, the Dubai Court failed to address the main issues between the parties, rendering its judgment not one on the merits of the case.
In Vimal Jeyachandran v. Diana Jerine Johnson, C.R.P.(MD) No. 2594 of 2022, decided on February 27, 2018 the Madras High Court highlighted the complexities involved in the matters related to domicile, international divorce, and jurisdictional conflicts. The couple, married in India under Christian rites, faced jurisdictional issues when the husband, who resided in the USA, obtained a divorce from a Minnesota court on grounds not recognised by Indian law. Despite the wife's objections and an Indian court's injunction, the foreign court granted the divorce. The High Court, finding lack of jurisdiction and no evidence of the wife’s domicile in USA, held the decree of the foreign court to be null and void.
In Arun A. v. The Marriage Officer (Sub-Registrar), WP(C) NO. 21638 OF 2023, decided on July 07, 2023 the Kerala High Court reiterated that foreign judgments can be accepted as conclusive in India where, irrespective of domicile in India, the parties voluntarily and effectively submit to the jurisdiction of the foreign court. The parties must also consent to the grant of the relief, even if the forum’s jurisdiction is not in accordance with the provisions of their matrimonial law.
ANALYSIS OF THE CONCEPT OF DOMICILE
From a reading of the authoritative pronouncement of the Supreme Court in Sondur Gopal (supra), it is clear and established beyond reasonable doubt that the principles governing domicile establish that domicile of origin prevails until another domicile is acquired and the intention to abandon the domicile of origin is firmly established. Such intention is material in determining whether the domicile of origin is retained. If there is no intention to abandon the domicile of origin, the domicile of choice cannot be presumed. The intention to abandon must be concrete and replete of all ingredients. Hence, if a person continues to retain agricultural land and household property in their country of origin with the intention of returning, no change in domicile of origin can be established, irrespective of the change in nationality of such person.
Further, the onus of proof of a change of domicile lies on the person who alleges it. Unless this is proved beyond reasonable doubt, no presumption of a change of domicile can arise. As a necessary corollary of this connotation, the domicile of origin is retained unless it is conclusively displaced by the domicile of choice. Therefore, if an incumbent expresses clear intention of retaining his domicile of origin, despite residing for an extended period in a stated domicile of choice and acquiring its nationality through naturalisation, there is no automatic presumption in law that the domicile of origin has been displaced. Consequently, a domicile of origin cannot be abandoned merely by a simple residence in a domicile of choice for different purposes.
Indian jurisprudence follows the principles of English law on domicile, as enunciated above and reaffirmed in the cited judgments. Accordingly, for the purposes of marriage and divorce, the domicile of origin cannot be considered abandoned or given up if the parties have relocated to India and no longer reside abroad. In such circumstances, any matrimonial decree or judgment issue by a foreign court will not be recognised in India due to the lack of domicile and jurisdiction.
DOMICILE IN MATTERS OF SUCCESSION AND INHERITANCE IN INDIA
The Indian Succession Act, 1925, as amended by The Indian Succession (Amendment) Act, 2002,(ISA) is an Act enacted by Parliament to consolidate the law applicable to intestate and testamentary succession. Part II of this Act deals with provisions relating to Domicile. Sections 5, 9, and 19 in Part II of the ISA, which is relevant to the present context, are quoted hereunder:
“5. Law regulating succession to a deceased person’s immovable and movable property, respectively.—(1) Succession to the immovable property in India of a person deceased shall be regulated by the law of India, wherever such person may have had his domicile at the time of his death.
(2) Succession to the movable property of a person deceased is regulated by the law of the country in which such person had his domicile at the time of his death.
9. Continuance of domicile of origin.—The domicile of origin prevails until a new domicile has been acquired.
19. Succession to movable property in India in the absence of proof of domicile elsewhere.—If a person dies leaving the movable property in India, in the absence of proof of any domicile elsewhere, succession to the property is regulated by the law of India.”
Supreme Court of India in R. Viswanathan v. Rukn-Ul-Mulk, AIR 1963 Supreme Court 1 while adjudicating on jurisdictional issues, held in paras 25 & 28, as extracted below:
“25. Title to immovable property may therefore be determined directly or indirectly only by the law of the State, and by the courts of the State in which it is situated. A decision of a foreign court directly relating to title to immovable property within its jurisdiction will of course be regarded between the same parties as conclusive by the courts in India: but that decision is ineffectual in the adjudication of claims to immovable without the jurisdiction of that foreign court, even if the foundation of title in both the jurisdictions is alleged to be identical. A foreign court being incompetent to try a suit relating to immovable property not situated within its jurisdiction, the grounds on which its decision relating to title to immovable property within its jurisdiction is founded will not debar investigation into title to other property within the jurisdiction of the municipal courts, even if the latter properties are alleged to be held on the same title. Every issue and every component of the issue relating to title to the immovable property must be decided by the court within whose jurisdiction it is situated: to recognise the authority of a foreign court to adjudicate upon even a component of that issue would be to recognise the authority of that court to decide all the components thereof.
28. ...Succession to the estate of a person is governed by the lex situs in the case of immovables, and in the case of movables by the law of his domicile...” (Emphasis supplied)
Similar views were expressed in Sankaran Govindan v. Lakshmi Bharathi and Ors., AIR 1964 Kerala 244 where the High Court of Kerala addressed the issues of succession involving a deceased individual who had lived in England for 30 years before dying intestate in England. In paras 29 and 35 of the judgment, the Court enunciated the principles, whereby, division of property would be governed, as described in following words in court’s verdict:
“29. In support of this proposition, the learned Advocate General invites our attention to Dicey on Conflict of Laws, 7th Edn Ch. 18, page 512. Rule 85 of Dicey says that all rights over, or in relation to, an immovable (land) are (subject to the Exceptions hereinafter mentioned) governed by the law of the country where the immovable is situated (lex situs). On page 520, Dicey again says that succession to immovables situated abroad, or of money representing such immovables, is determined by whatever system of law the lex situs would apply. The learned author says further that the lex situs determines, among other things, who is entitled to succeed to the immovables. To the same effect is the passage appearing in Cheshire, 6th Edn., on page 603. Cheshire says that where the owner of immovables dies intestate, the order of descent or distribution prescribed by the lex situs is applied by the English court, no matter what his domicile may have been.
35. According to us, the principle that should apply to the house left by Dr. Krishnan in England in the present case is the same. On the finding that Dr. Krishnan had not lost his domicile of origin, his immovable properties in India and all his movables, whether in India or England, should be divided according to the law of succession in India. And succession to the house in England, being immovable property according to the law of the situs as applied to Conflict of Laws, should be decided under the English law of succession. The subsequent conversion of that immovable into money does not also alter this position. Hence, we are of the opinion that the lower court was in error in treating the sale proceeds of the house as movable property and applying the law of succession applicable to Ezhavas in Travancore.” (Emphasis supplied).
SUCCESSION TO PROPERTY IN INDIA
From a reading of the above, it can be conclusively stated that insofar immovable property in India is concerned, it shall be governed by the law in India. Any adjudication pertaining to such immovable property shall lie within the domain of Indian courts, even if the foundation of title to such immovable property is identical in both Indian and foreign jurisdictions. Hence, if a testator living abroad—but with a permanent domicile of origin in India—leaves behind immovable property in both India and abroad, the succession of immovable property in India will be governed by Indian laws, and foreign laws will not find application to such properties in India.
For all matters related to the disposition of property, the law of succession and the law of taxation, Indian law will apply to both immovable and movable properties of a person domiciled in India, who has not lost his domicile of origin, even if he resides abroad. However, in respect of movable and immovable properties located in a foreign country where a person resides or dies, succession, taxation, and all other related issues will be governed as per the laws of that foreign country. But, insofar as a person who has retained his domicile of origin, all his movable and immovable properties located in India will be governed by the Indian law of succession and taxation for all purposes.
JUDGMENTS ON DIVORCE DECREES FROM FOREIGN DOMICILES
In Smt. Satya v. Teja Singh, AIR 1975 SC 105, Supreme Court held as hereunder:
“52. Unhappily, the marriage between the appellant and respondent has to limp. They will be treated as divorced in Nevada but their bond of matrimony will remain unsnapped in India, the country of their domicile. This view, it is urged for the respondent, will lead to difficulties. It may. But ‘these rules of private international law are made for men and women—not the other way round—and a nice tidy logical perfection can never be achieved’
This is a landmark judgment on the concept of domicile and elaborates its significance in matrimonial matters and non-recognition of foreign divorce decrees.
In Smt. Joyce Sumathi v. Robert Dickson Brodie, AIR 1982 Andhra Pradesh 389 the Andhra Pradesh Court addressed Section 27 of the Special Marriage Act (SMA), 1954 and Sections 18, 17, 4, and 27 of the Foreign Marriage Act (FMA), 1969. The Court had to consider the question of maintainability of a divorce petition filed by an Indian citizen under Section 27 of the SMA read with Section 18 of the FMA, in respect of a foreign marriage solemnised abroad where parties were domiciled. The marriage was not registered under Section 17 of the FMA. There was nothing on record to show that the conditions relating to solemnisation of foreign marriage were contravened. Hence, the Court held that “there can, therefore, be no doubt that the marriage between the parties was a valid marriage”. It was held that the appellant being an Indian citizen was entitled to maintain a petition under the SMA, as any party to a marriage which was solemnised under the FMA is entitled to do so. The petition for divorce made under Section 27 of the SMA read with Section 18 of the FMA was held to be maintainable as domicile was not a contested issue in this case. The parties were merely seeking divorce under the SMA in respect of a marriage solemnised abroad under the FMA.
In Deepalakshmi v. K. Murugesh, 2010 (4) Recent Civil Reports Civil 956, the husband and wife were Indian citizens who got married in India and chose domicile in the USA. In the divorce petition filed by one spouse in India, it was held that the courts in India would have the jurisdiction, not the courts in the USA. The foreign domicile of one of the spouses was immaterial and the permanent domicile in India prevailed. It was also the fact that parties were married under the HMA, which was the applicable personal law in their case.
In S. Saravanan v. Deepa, 2011 (2) Recent Civil Reports (Civil) 901 the parties left to reside in a foreign country after a marriage was performed in India as per the HMA. The Court held that the judgment of a foreign court dissolving such marriage is not enforceable in India, as the parties were married in accordance with the provisions of the HMA, which had extraterritorial application.
In Bhashyam Ramesh @ Rajagopalan v. R. Saroja @ K.K. Saroja, 2013 (1) HLR 123 (Madras) both parties were Hindus and their marriage had taken place in India. Here, the Court ruled that the parties were automatically subjected to the jurisdiction of courts (Family Court) designated to deal with matrimonial disputes under Section 19 of the HMA. The husband, however, upon shifting to the United States, initiated divorce proceedings before the Superior Court of California and got the marriage dissolved. The Madras High Court ruled that the marriage between the appellant and the respondent could be dissolved only on the grounds set out under Section 13 of the HMA. The Superior Court of California was not a court of competent jurisdiction and only the Family Court in India had complete competency and jurisdiction. The temporary domicile of the husband in the USA would give him no benefit and he could not pursue any matrimonial petition in the USA according to their laws.
In Rupak Rathi v. Anita Chaudhary, 2014 (2) Hindu Law Reporter (Punjab and Haryana) 96 a Hindu couple got married in India according to Hindu rites and set up their matrimonial home in the UK. A decree of divorce was granted by a UK court on ground of irretrievable breakdown of marriage. However, the Punjab & Haryana High Court ruled that the decree of divorce was not valid in India. The Court further held that the temporary domicile of the parties in the UK would confer no benefit of dissolving the marriage in the UK. Under the HMA, irretrievable breakdown of marriage is no ground of divorce. The Court was held that:
“(i) No decree of divorce obtained from the English Court on a ground not available under the HMA can be sustained on ground of irretrievable break down of marriage.
(ii) Where parties confer jurisdiction on the foreign court, the said Court will assume jurisdiction available to the Matrimonial Court in India but would remain confined to adjudicate the action in accordance with the matrimonial law of the parties, i.e., the HMA and the grounds available therein.
(iii) The legal position is that when a Hindu couple tied by the nuptial knot according to Hindu rites travel abroad with intention to settle down and reside there is to set up matrimonial home, they carry their personal laws on their back, off-loading it in a foreign court for adjudication. 2003(2) RCR (Civil) 197, relied.”
In Shilpa Sachdev v. Anand Sachdev 2017 (3) HLR 178 Bombay High Court (DB), the husband and wife were Indian citizens who had shifted to Dubai. The wife came back after a few years and the husband obtained a decree of divorce from a Dubai court. The Bombay High Court was of the view that the judgment of the Dubai court was neither binding nor enforceable in India. Parties were married in India as per Hindu rites and had shifted to Dubai, where after some time, their son and daughter were born. Thereafter, the wife returned India and the husband got a decree of divorce on the ground of desertion by wife from the Dubai Court. The Bombay High Court held that since the parties were Hindus and held a permanent domicile in India, the Dubai divorce decree had no legal sanctity, even though the husband was domiciled in Dubai.
From a collective reading of judgments above, it can be concluded that a temporary domicile abroad, whilst the permanent domicile in India is retained, does not vest jurisdiction in foreign courts to decide matrimonial disputes simply because one or both spouses have set up their matrimonial abode in that foreign jurisdiction. The HMA has extraterritorial application to Hindus who are domiciled in India but reside outside the Indian territory. Thus, foreign domiciles in such cases do not vest jurisdiction in foreign courts.
ANALYSIS OF FOREIGN DOMICILE
In determining the nature of a domicile of choice, the Court in Rosetta Evelyn Attaullah AIR 1953 Calcutta 530 outlined four essential conditions for establishing the necessary intention. First, the intention must amount to a clear purpose or choice, although judicial opinions vary on how definite this intention must be. Some rulings suggest that a person need not have a fully formed intention, while others require more explicit evidence that the intention existed or would have been formed if the issue of domicile had arisen. Second, the intention must be to reside permanently or indefinitely; temporary stays, even for extended periods, do not constitute a change in domicile. Third, there must be an intention to abandon the previous domicile; this intention must be genuine and not contingent upon uncertain future events. Finally, it is not necessary for the intention to change domicile to include a change of allegiance, although more recent cases have nuanced this position.
The principles derived from these judgments underscore that the domicile of origin prevails until a new domicile is conclusively established, with a clear and demonstrable intention to abandon the original domicile. Intention is pivotal in retaining or changing domicile. If an individual retains property or maintains a connection with their domicile of origin to return, no change in domicile can be presumed, even if the person has changed their nationality. Moreover, the burden of proving a change in domicile lies with the party asserting it. Without clear evidence, the presumption is that the domicile of origin remains. This principle reflects the broader legal stance that the domicile of origin is retained unless decisively displaced by a domicile of choice.
Therefore, even if a person has resided in a new country for an extended period and acquired citizenship therein, domicile of origin remains, unless there is an unequivocal intention to adopt the new domicile permanently. Indian jurisprudence, as demonstrated in the aforementioned judgments, aligns closely with English law principles regarding domicile. The courts in India continue to follow these established principles, ensuring that any change in domicile is substantiated by clear and convincing evidence encompassing residence and the intention to abandon the previous domicile. Thus, the concept of domicile, deeply rooted in both English and Indian law, remains a critical factor in legal determinations related to personal status, succession, and jurisdiction.
*Author, a practising Senior Advocate, has ten books pertaining to issues of private international law. He can be reached at anilmalhotra1960@gmail.com. www.anilmalhotra.co.in
Advocate, Malhotra & Malhotra Associates, India.
LL.M [London]&Felix Scholar, School of Oriental &African Studies, University of London, London.
Email: contact@ankitmalhotra.org,
Website:https://www.ankitmalhotra.org.in



Comments